Planning a murder mystery dinner party game and wondering what to serve that doesn’t require an ID check at the door? Some guests may simply prefer a festive drink without the alcohol, and there are plenty of great options to enjoy. From classy mocktails to killer punch bowls, we’ve stirred up some nonalcoholic drink ideas that pair perfectly with the plot twists and dramatic gasps of a murder mystery game night.

What’s inside this post:

• Mocktails for every mystery
• Themed drinks that match the vibe
• Family-friendly ideas that wow
• Where to get all the mystery

And if you’re thinking of putting on the whole show yourself—scripts, characters, clues and all—well, let’s just say that’s one way to commit… to stress. Instead, let The Murder Mystery Company take care of the thrills while you focus on picking the perfect themed beverages to toast the whodunnit chaos.

---

Drinks That Match the Mystery Theme

Whether it’s a 1920s speakeasy, a masquerade ball, or a mob wedding, your drink choices can help set the tone. Here are some party-perfect pairings:

• Midnight at the Masquerade: Serve sparkling blackberry lemonade in coupe glasses with a sugar rim. It’s dark, mysterious, and just fancy enough to make guests feel like they’re sipping secrets.
• Death of a Gangster: Try a classic Italian soda bar! Cherry, vanilla, or blood orange flavors with a splash of club soda and crushed ice—served in old-school soda shop glasses with striped straws.
• Best Laid Plans: Roll out the red carpet with gold-rimmed plastic flutes filled with ginger-pear mocktails. Bonus points if there’s a Maraschino cherry for drama.
• Til Death Do Us Part: Go romantic with a rose lemonade punch—pink lemonade, rose water, and lemon slices floating in a punch bowl that screams “I do… love this drink.”
• A Dance with Death: Serve up a strawberry lemon fizz punch—a mix of strawberry purée, fresh-squeezed lemon juice, and sparkling water over crushed ice. It’s bright, bubbly, and just tart enough to keep everyone guessing.

---

Crowd-Pleasing Mocktails for Any Mystery

Not sure what your guests will be into? Go for tried-and-true mocktail recipes that are just as fun as they are photogenic:

• The Cucumber Conspiracy: Cucumber, lime, and tonic water with a sprig of mint. Fresh, clean, and suspiciously refreshing.
• The Smoking Gun: Dry ice over apple cider or root beer for a smoky effect that gives off serious detective vibes.
• The Red Herring: Pomegranate juice, lemon-lime soda, and a splash of cranberry. Tart, fizzy, and misleading in the best way.
• The Innocent Bystander: Coconut water, pineapple juice, and lime—because sometimes the quiet ones have the best flavor.

These drinks don’t just taste great—they also make your mystery dinner party photos look top-tier. Your guests will be raising their glasses and eyebrows in equal measure.

---

Add a Twist with DIY Drink Stations

If you’re looking for a way to keep everyone mingling, set up a DIY mocktail bar. Let guests build their own concoctions with mixers, juices, garnishes, and a chalkboard sign full of punny drink names (ex: “Crime & Lime,” “Blood Orange Alibi”).

With so many charming mom-and-pop coffee shops popping up, it’s no surprise that mobile espresso bars are having a moment. Hiring a traveling coffee cart adds a cozy, caffeinated touch to your event—perfect for fueling late-night sleuthing. Picture a suspect sipping a cappuccino mid-interrogation or guests comparing clues over lattes. It’s a killer combo of ambiance and energy.

This works especially well for family parties or teen-friendly events where everyone wants to feel grown-up without actually being grown up. Want to go a step further? Add a “Murder Mystery Mugshot Station” backdrop from The Murder Mystery Company to snap their drink-worthy mug… shots.

---

Let The Murder Mystery Company Handle the Plot

You’ve got the drinks covered—but who’s bringing the mystery? Instead of downloading a last-minute script and hoping your cousin Bob has the acting chops of Daniel Craig, let The Murder Mystery Company bring the drama.

Their actors bring costumes, clues, and chaos to keep your guests entertained and immersed, while you sit back with your mocktail masterpiece. Whether it’s a party of 8 or a crowd of 500, they’ll help you host an interactive mystery game that’s easy to plan and unforgettable to play.

Contact The Murder Mystery Company at 888-643-2583 or fill out one of the contact forms on the page you’re viewing now. We’ll help you host a night where the only thing missing… is the culprit.