< Blog Party Ideas

The Best Murder Mystery Themes for an Unforgettable Party

April 11, 2025

Planning a party that stands out from the usual crowd? A murder mystery party is the perfect way to turn a gathering into an experience. With dramatic twists, colorful characters, and laugh-out-loud moments, it’s a mix of theater, mystery, and just enough mischief to keep everyone guessing. The real fun? Picking the murder mystery theme that sets the tone—and the costumes—for the entire night.

When it comes to murder mystery dinners, The Murder Mystery Company knows how to deliver the drama, no DIY stress required. Whether it’s a holiday office party, a birthday blowout, or even a wedding reception with a killer twist, there’s a theme that’ll fit like a vintage glove.


Dress the Part: Decades That Dazzle

Few things are more fun than dressing up in costumes inspired by decades past. The right era sets the mood—and the murder scene.

The Roaring 1920s:
Cue the jazz, feathers, and flapper dresses. This is a time of speakeasies and secret passwords. Our theme Death of a Gangster is perfect for a mobster vibe where everyone’s hiding something (including the killer).

The Glamorous 1930s:
Think Art Deco elegance and old Hollywood mystery. This decade adds a touch of class and a whole lot of drama—perfect for an upscale murder mystery dinner. Our theme Best Laid Plans would be a smart match!

The Sock Hop 1950s:
Poodle skirts and leather jackets aren’t just for Halloween. Picture a high school dance turned deadly and you’ve got our theme A Dance with Death!

The Bold 1980s:
Neon colors, big hair, and bigger secrets. The I Love the 80s to Death theme is totally rad for anyone who loves nostalgia, over-the-top outfits, and surprise betrayals.

The Cool 1990s:
Take a trip back to the days of mixtapes, chokers, and chain emails. The ’90s theme Good Riddance may not seem vintage (yet), but it makes for an unexpectedly fun—and funny—murder mystery backdrop.


Why Themes Matter (and Why You Shouldn’t Plan Alone)

The theme you choose sets everything from the storyline to the costumes. Want an elegant gala mystery full of shadows and secrets? Midnight at the Masquerade would be the sophisticated choice. Or perhaps you’d like to celebrate the holidays with your closest friends… and foes? You’ll be in the right place with The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year. The Murder Mystery Company can help match your event to a theme that delivers laughs, suspense, and the perfect dose of theatrical flair.

Even better—they handle the hard stuff. No worrying about scripts, timelines, or whether Aunt Nancy will actually play along. Their team of professional actors keeps the show running smoothly, and the guests immersed in the fun. You just get to enjoy the ride.


Time to Plan a Killer Night

No matter the crowd, there’s a murder mystery theme that will leave guests delighted and a little suspicious of each other (in the best way). So forget awkward mingling and stale party games—choose a theme, throw on a costume, and let The Murder Mystery Company do the rest.

Ready to get started? Call 888-643-2583 or fill out one of the contact forms on this page to bring a professionally produced murder mystery party to life.

Host your own Mystery Party!

Our Murder Mystery Experts are excited to talk to you about your personalized party plans.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.