When the drama’s hot and the clues are cold, nothing hits the spot like a themed coffee to sip between accusations. Whether you’re hosting a murder mystery party at home or letting the pros at The Murder Mystery Company take care of it all, a curated coffee bar can elevate your night from “fun gathering” to “legendary event.”

But first… coffee.

What’s served up in this blog:

• Themed drinks for mystery lovers
• Signature sips for each whodunnit
• Coffee bar ideas for the big night
• How to host with no guesswork

Let’s stir up some suspiciously delicious drinks for your next mystery night…

---

“Death of a Gangster” – The Flapper’s Flat White

Set in the roaring 1920s, this mafia wedding mystery is full of speakeasy secrets and vintage glam. Pair it with a Flapper’s Flat White: smooth, elegant, and just a little dangerous.

Recipe:

• 2 shots espresso
• 4 oz steamed milk
• ½ tsp vanilla syrup
• Sprinkle of cinnamon for drama

Serve in dainty teacups or etched glassware for that bootleg charm. Paired with Death of a Gangster.

---

“Midnight at the Masquerade” – The Mocha Masquerade

This modern masquerade ball is full of intrigue behind every mask. Guests in cocktail attire and feather boas need a drink as rich as the secrets they’re hiding.

Recipe:

• 2 shots espresso
• 2 oz dark chocolate syrup
• 6 oz steamed milk
• Topped with whipped cream and edible gold dust

It’s mysterious, over-the-top, and perfect for sipping while pointing fingers. Paired with Midnight at the Masquerade.

---

“I Love the 80s to Death” – Totally Tubular Cold Brew

Big hair. Bigger accusations. This neon nightmare is best served chilled—like your blood when the lights go out.

Recipe:

• 6 oz cold brew concentrate
• 2 oz sweet cream (half & half + vanilla syrup)
• Rainbow sprinkles on top (trust us)
• Served over ice in a retro party cup

Perfect for solving a murder to the beat of a synth-pop playlist. Paired with I Love the 80s To Death.

---

“A Dance With Death” – The 1950s Diner Doppio

Set in a rockin’ 1950s prom with swing skirts and dark secrets, this mystery calls for a classic with a punch.

Recipe:

• Double shot of espresso
• 1 tsp maple syrup
• Dash of bitters (optional)
• Garnish with a cherry on top

Serve in a tall sundae glass to match your soda shop vibes. Paired with A Dance with Death.

---

“Best Laid Plans” – The Mansion Macchiato

If you’re after that classic Clue-style mystery set in a posh mansion, this drink is as layered as the suspects.

Recipe:

• 1 shot espresso
• 1 oz caramel syrup
• Foamed milk on top
• Drizzle of caramel and a pretzel stick “dagger” garnish

It’s rich, salty-sweet, and keeps you sharp through every twist and turn. Paired with Best Laid Plans.

---

“Now You See It, Now You Don’t” – The Kid-Friendly Choco-Latte

Hosting a mystery for a younger crowd or looking for a murder-free mystery? This diamond-heist caper is caffeine-free and kid-approved.

Recipe:

• 6 oz steamed milk
• 2 tbsp chocolate syrup
• A drop of peppermint extract
• Topped with marshmallows and rainbow dust

Perfect for little detectives and grown-up sweet tooths alike. Paired with Now You See It, Now You Don’t.

---

How to Set Up a Murder Mystery Coffee Bar

You don’t have to stick to just one beverage! A DIY coffee bar is the perfect killer companion. Here’s how to serve up a murder mystery experience that’s full of buzz:

1. Create a “Suspect Menu”
Rename your drinks to match the mystery. Think The Cold Brew Killer, Latte Lie Detector, or Cappuccino Conspiracy. Bonus points for printing out a menu styled like a police report.

2. Set the Scene
Use chalkboard signs, burlap sacks, vintage mugs, and candlesticks to give your setup a moody, noir feel. A little dry ice in a punch bowl can add a foggy, mysterious vibe if you’re feeling extra.

3. Offer Clue-Themed Mix-Ins
Create a topping station with “evidence” labels:

• Fingerprints (cocoa powder)
• Confessions (caramel drizzle)
• Alibis (whipped cream)
• Blood Spatter (cherry syrup)

4. Assign a Barista
Have someone dress as a quirky barista character—complete with apron, fake name tag, and dramatic flair. They can serve drinks with a wink and drop cryptic hints to keep the mystery brewing.

---

Skip the Grind—We’ll Brew the Mystery

Love the idea of a coffee-fueled caper but don’t want to roast yourself trying to plan it? Let The Murder Mystery Company take care of the mystery part while you bring the beans. With immersive shows, professional actors, and unforgettable themes, they’ll turn your gathering into a full-on interactive mystery game.

Whether it’s a birthday bash, corporate party, or just an excuse to drink lattes and accuse your friends, a mystery dinner party is always a good idea.

Visit The Murder Mystery Company to find the perfect theme, and let them do the dirty (but delightful) work of staging a killer evening. Want help now? Call 888-643-2583 or fill out a contact form right on the page you’re reading.

Just don’t forget the coffee.