Planning a masquerade murder mystery party? Before the clues are uncovered and the suspects start pointing fingers, one thing needs to be absolutely killer: the food. A themed party deserves more than chips in a bowl—it deserves a spread that’s as dramatic and decadent as the event itself.

What You’ll Find Below:

• Elegant hor d’oeuvres with mystery flair
• Entrees to die for
• Mask-worthy drinks and desserts
• Why themed food boosts immersion

Whether your masquerade leans Venetian glam or modern masquerade ball, one thing’s for sure: you want dishes that match the drama. Let’s unmask the menu.

---

Mouthwatering Starters That Break the Ice

Finger food is your best friend at a mystery dinner party, especially when guests need one hand for a cocktail and the other for clue cards.

• Stuffed Mushrooms of Mystery – Elegant, bite-sized, and perfect for suspicious snacking
• Bruschetta Bar – Offer toppings like tomato-basil, olive tapenade, and smoked salmon. Everyone loves a choice…
• Mini Caprese Skewers – Fancy enough for the masquerade, easy enough to vanish without silverware
• Prosciutto-Wrapped Asparagus – Flavorful and easy to eat while eavesdropping on potential killers

These light appetizers keep people mingling, sleuthing, and building up to the next big reveal—dinner.

---

Entrees Worth Killing For

Even the most dramatic plot twist can’t compete with a meal that wows. For a masquerade-themed mystery dinner party game, the entrée should feel lush and theatrical.

• Chicken Marsala – Rich, saucy, and Italian-inspired
• Filet Medallions – Tender cuts that practically scream “high society dinner party”
• Wild Mushroom Risotto – A vegetarian option that feels upscale and decadent
• Butternut Squash Ravioli with Brown Butter Sage Sauce – Rich, golden, and dramatic enough to rival the plot twists

These dishes are more than meals—they’re immersive tools that help guests feel like they’ve stepped into another world.

---

Decadent Desserts and Disappearing Acts

Now for the sweet ending. In a masquerade-themed murder mystery event, desserts should dazzle and disappear mysteriously fast.

• Masquerade Mask Cookies – Sugar cookies with icing masks? A Pinterest dream come true.
• Chocolate Mousse Cups – Rich and mysterious, like the killer’s alibi
• Berry Tartlets – Small, sweet, and perfect for those still nursing a glass of wine
• Red Velvet Cake Bites – These crimson beauties add a splash of color—and a suspiciously fitting nod to blood-red motives

Bonus: You can even serve dessert right before the final accusation. Who doesn’t want a little sugar with their suspense?

---

Masked Cocktails and Mocktails

No mystery dinner party is complete without drinks to toast the night’s drama.

• Blackberry Bellinis – Bubbly and mysterious
• “Killer” Sangria – Red wine with floating fruit and just a hint of menace
• Lavender Lemonade – A non-alcoholic option with a floral twist (served in a goblet, of course)
• “The Alibi” – Blood Orange Margarita – A tart and mysterious drink that might make guests forget where they were at the time of the crime.

A signature drink also gives guests something to hold as they whisper suspicions and eye each other suspiciously.

---

The Magic of Matching Food to Theme

Themed food isn’t just fun—it pulls guests deeper into the world. When a meal feels like it belongs in a grand masked mansion or an elegant gala, the story feels more real. The stakes feel higher. And trust us, nothing makes a dinner party more memorable than feeling like you’re the lead character in a murder mystery movie.

The Murder Mystery Company plays nice with any dining setup. Planning a buffet? It’s the perfect pre-show icebreaker—guests can grab a plate before the mystery begins and sneak in a second helping between clue hunting. Prefer a plated dinner? A three-course meal fits seamlessly with our three-act show structure, turning each course into a dramatic pause in the action. Whether it’s self-serve or silver service, we’ll make sure the dining experience works hand-in-glove with the night’s intrigue.

---

Let The Murder Mystery Company Set the Table

We get it—crafting the perfect menu, running the game, wrangling guests in costume… that’s a lot of hats (or masks) to wear.

The Murder Mystery Company takes the pressure off by handling the entire murder mystery game for you. You pick the date, the theme (may we suggest Midnight at the Masquerade?), and your dream guest list—we’ll bring the mystery, drama, and a show your guests will talk about long after dessert.

Give us a call at 888-643-2583 or fill out one of the contact forms on this page to get started. We’ll help you plan a themed mystery party that’s as unforgettable as it is delicious.