Throwing a murder mystery party is already a recipe for a memorable evening, but pair it with the perfect wine? Now you’re speaking our language. Every themed mystery comes with its own flavor—literally and figuratively—and the right bottle can elevate the night from “fun” to “fabulously unforgettable.” Whether you’re planning a Gatsby-style gangster soirée or a retro prom gone wrong, this list is your no-fuss guide to serving wines that match the mystery.

What You’ll Find in This Blog:

• Themes meet their wine match
• Easy wine picks by era
• Wine suggestions for red and white

Of course, if you really want to kill it (pun very intended), The Murder Mystery Company can take care of the whole experience—plot, cast, clues, and yes, even helping you pick the right mood-setting music and wine vibe.

---

Midnight at the Masquerade + Pinot Noir or Champagne

This modern-day masquerade ball, set in the opulent Billionaires’ Club, calls for wines that exude elegance and mystery.

• Pinot Noir – Smooth and nuanced, perfect for an evening of intrigue.
• Champagne – Bubbly and celebratory, ideal for unmasking secrets.​

---

Death of a Gangster + Chianti or Prosecco

Step into the 1920s mafia wedding scene with wines that echo the era’s charm.

• Chianti – Rustic and bold, complements Italian fare and mobster tales.
• Prosecco – Light and bubbly, a nod to speakeasy celebrations.​

---

Best Laid Plans + Cabernet Sauvignon or Chardonnay

Immerse yourself in a 1930s Hollywood whodunnit with wines that match the glamour.

• Cabernet Sauvignon – Rich and full-bodied, befitting a classic mystery.
• Chardonnay – Smooth and sophisticated, mirrors the old Hollywood allure.​

---

I Love the 80’s to Death + Zinfandel or Lambrusco

Relive the radical 1980s rock concert vibe with wines that are as bold as the era.

• Zinfandel – Jammy and robust, pairs well with energetic settings.
• Lambrusco – Fizzy and fun, captures the decade’s playful spirit.

---

A Dance With Death + Rosé or Riesling

Transport to a 1950s sock hop gone sour with wines that are sweet and nostalgic.

• Rosé – Light and fruity, perfect for a prom night setting.
• Riesling – Sweet and aromatic, complements the era’s innocence.​

---

Til Death Do Us Part + Merlot or Sauvignon Blanc

Navigate a modern-day wedding with a twist, choosing wines that balance drama and delight.

• Merlot – Soft and approachable, eases the tension of nuptial nightmares.
• Sauvignon Blanc – Crisp and refreshing, cuts through the wedding chaos.​

---

The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year + Mulled Wine or Pinot Grigio

Celebrate a festive holiday mystery with wines that warm and delight.

• Mulled Wine – Spiced and cozy, embodies holiday cheer.
• Pinot Grigio – Light and crisp, balances rich seasonal dishes.​

---

Good Riddance + White Zinfandel or Moscato

Dive into a gnarly 1990s setting with wines that are as vibrant as the decade.

• White Zinfandel – Sweet and pink, a 90s party staple.
• Moscato – Versatile and popular, reflects the era’s trends.​

---

Now You See It Now You Don’t + Sparkling Grape Juice or Syrah

This modern-day diamond heist mystery is perfect for junior sleuths and family-friendly fun. So naturally, the drink pairings need to reflect both the sparkle of a high-stakes theft and the age range of your guest list.

• Sparkling Grape Juice – A nonalcoholic crowd-pleaser that lets kids and teens feel part of the action while sipping something celebratory.
• Syrah – For the grown-up gumshoes, this bold red offers deep flavors and just enough edge to match the thrill of chasing down a jewel thief.

---

Ready to pour some fun into your next party?

Call 888-643-2583 or fill out a contact form on this page to start planning your wine-soaked whodunnit with The Murder Mystery Company.