Planning a night out on Broadway? You’re probably excited about the show, but the
thought of finding somewhere to eat beforehand can be daunting. The area around
Broadway is packed with restaurants, but that doesn’t make it any easier to find a good
spot to enjoy a meal before the curtain rises. You may have scoured reviews and top-
ten lists of the best restaurants by Broadway, but once you’re there, you might
find it’s not so simple to get a table.

The Waiting Game: A Pre-Show Dining Dilemma

One of the biggest challenges of dining near Broadway is the wait time. Even if you
make a reservation, it’s common to encounter delays. And if you didn’t book ahead?
Prepare for a painfully long wait. Restaurants around the theater district are often
bustling, especially as showtime approaches. You might think you have plenty of time,
only to find yourself anxiously checking your watch as you wait for your meal.

Navigating the crowded streets of Manhattan is a task in itself, and once you finally
secure a table, there’s no guarantee the service will be quick. The fear of missing the
opening act can turn what should be a relaxing dinner into a stressful race against the
clock.

The Hassle-Free Solution: Dinner and a Show at Carmine’s

So, what’s the alternative? How can you enjoy a great meal without the stress of waiting
or rushing? That’s where Carmine’s comes in with their unique dinner and a show
experience. Located right in the heart of Times Square, Carmine’s offers an interactive
murder mystery show that solves your dining dilemma.

Not only do you get to enjoy a delicious three-course meal, but you also dive into the
roaring 1920s with a cast of characters straight out of a classic crime novel. At
Carmine’s, you’ll step into the world of the Lou Zar Speakeasy, where intrigue and
murder are on the menu. The show wraps up around 6:30 PM, leaving you with plenty
of time to stroll to your Broadway show without the stress of missing a single note.

Why Carmine’s is the Perfect Pre-Show Choice

Choosing Carmine’s for your pre-show plans means more than just enjoying a meal.
You get a full evening of entertainment that blends perfectly with your Broadway
experience. There’s no rush, no waiting, and no stress—just a fun, immersive night that
puts you in the perfect mood for whatever show you’re about to see.

So, the next time you’re wondering where to eat before a Broadway show, skip the
frantic search for the best restaurants by Broadway. Instead, make your evening a
seamless blend of great food and thrilling entertainment at Carmine’s. By the time you
leave, you’ll have solved a murder, enjoyed a hearty Italian dinner, and still have time to
spare before your Broadway adventure begins.

Experience the Murder Mystery Show at Carmine’s

Step into the Lou Zar Speakeasy, where the drinks and clues are endlessly flowing.
What appears to be a legitimate Italian restaurant quickly reveals its true nature as an
illegal speakeasy run by a mafia family, teeming with seedy characters. With members
of the mob in attendance, tensions are high, and someone is bound to lose an eye… or
even their life!

An Immersive 1920s Adventure

Don your best flapper dress, hop on the trolley, and head down to Carmine’s in NYC for
an exciting murder mystery dinner theater show that you’ll never forget. Our interactive
performance allows you to become part of the story, whether you’re acting as a suspect
or working as a detective to uncover the murderer among you.

Show Details

• Location: Carmine’s Times Square, NYC
• Showtimes: The murder mystery show concludes by 6:30 PM, providing ample time to make it to your Broadway show. Later shows are also available, so if you’re looking for a late bite, the second shows on Fridays and Saturdays start at 7:30 PM.
• Date Availability: Check our calendar for upcoming show dates and times. See the show calendar.

What to Expect

1. Assigning Roles: Upon arrival, our actors mingle with guests, selecting 8-12
   attendees to act as ‘suspects’. If you’re not a suspect, you’ll take on the role of a
   ‘detective’, tasked with scrutinizing scenes and interrogating suspects during
   investigation periods.
2. The Performance Kicks Off: The excitement escalates as the ‘murder’ occurs.
   The show spans three acts, providing multiple opportunities to observe
   interactions and gather clues.
3. Crack the Case!: Collaborate with your tablemates to piece together who had
   the motive, opportunity, and means to commit the crime. There is only one
   correct answer for each show, so your detective skills will be put to the test!

Why Choose Our Murder Mystery Dinner at Carmine’s?

• Interactive Experience: Engage directly with the storyline and characters, making your dinner an unforgettable adventure.
• Delicious Three-Course Meal: Enjoy Carmine’s favorite Italian dishes, served family style to complement the evening’s excitement.
• Award-Winning Show: As seen on ABC’s “Shark Tank”, our murder mystery dinners are praised for their engaging plots and stellar performances.
• Perfect Timing: With the show ending at 6:30 PM, you have plenty of time to transition smoothly to your Broadway performance without any hassle.

Get Your Tickets Today!

Don’t let the stress of finding where to eat before a Broadway show dampen your night
out. Join us at Carmine’s for a dinner and murder mystery experience that promises fun,
intrigue, and a fantastic meal—all in one seamless package.
Get Tickets