Not every murder is created equal—at least not when it comes to mystery party themes. Some are sweet and silly, others are bold and boozy, and most fall somewhere right in between. That’s why The Murder Mystery Company uses a simple rating system to help you find the perfect theme for your group: Kids, Adults, and No Restrictions.
Each theme is packed with excitement, character roles, clever clues, and just enough chaos. The difference? The tone, language, and style—so let’s break it all down before the sleuthing begins.
Kids Rated Themes: For Sleuths of All Ages
Need a party that’s fun for everyone from Grandma to grade schoolers? Themes rated Kids are made for exactly that. These stories skip the edgy jokes and mature content but keep all the suspense and fun. Characters are quirky, not scandalous. Plots are clever, not crass. And yes—there’s still a murder to solve, but in a lighthearted, Scooby-Doo-meets-Clue kind of way. So what themes do The Murder Mystery Company offer that are E for everyone?
- Now You See It, Now You Don’t – A sleek, modern-day diamond heist, Now You See It is designed for those moments when the intrigue of a mystery is desired—without involving a murder. Curated specifically for younger audiences, this 90-minute experience delivers a fast-paced, engaging story that’s both age-appropriate and captivating. It’s an ideal choice for kids’ birthday parties and family-focused events looking for interactive entertainment with a touch of suspense.
- Midnight at the Masquerade – One of the most popular and versatile themes in The Murder Mystery Company’s repertoire, this contemporary billionaires’ gala offers broad appeal and flexibility. It is also available with our unique “Gentle” rating—a family-focused alternative similar to our “Kids” version. While it omits more mature elements like romantic affairs, it retains the energy and wit that keep adult audiences engaged. The Gentle rating is particularly well-suited for corporate events and family gatherings that prefer a cleaner, all-ages-friendly experience.
Whether you’re throwing a birthday bash, a school event, or a holiday get-together, these family-friendly mysteries are perfect for keeping things safe, silly, and wildly entertaining.
Great for:
- Kids birthdays
- Family reunions
- School groups and fundraisers
- Church socials and community centers
Adults Rated Themes: A Little Sass, A Lot of Laughs
Looking for that just right balance of smart humor and interactive fun? Themes rated Adults are your go-to. These shows are written to entertain grown-up audiences without crossing the line—think a clever sitcom with a murder twist. There might be a flirtatious character or two, some cheeky banter, and the occasional innuendo pun that flies over the kids’ heads (if they’re even invited). These themes are ages 16 and up.
These themes will contain: Affairs, light innuendo, alcohol references
- Death of a Gangster – When most people think of a murder mystery, their minds often jump to gangsters and the glamour of the Roaring ’20s. Death of a Gangster delivers on that expectation with a classic 1920s storyline centered around two rival mafia families attempting to unite through marriage. Not everyone, however, is on board with this union—and some poor shmuck is gonna end up sleeping with the fishes. This theme is a crowd favorite, especially for guests who love to dress up in vintage style, making it a standout choice for an unforgettable and energetic evening out.
- Best Laid Plans – For those seeking the classic intrigue of CLUE with a touch of vintage glamour, Best Laid Plans is the perfect fit. Set in the dazzling 1930s during Hollywood’s Golden Age, the mystery unfolds at the lavish estate of eccentric film producer Sir Warren Peace. He’s invited a colorful cast of friends, rivals, and industry insiders for an evening of high drama—and deadly consequences. Packed with twists, turns, and theatrical flair, this theme is ideal for guests who love a challenge and a bit of old-school sophistication.
- A Dance with Death – Step back in time and relive the magic of prom night in this rollicking 1950s sock hop—though not everything goes according to plan for our cast of all-American high schoolers. With jukebox jams, poodle skirts, and more than a little drama on the dance floor, this theme delivers nostalgic charm in spades. Whether you’re hosting a lively ticketed event or entertaining at a senior community, it’s a real crowd-pleaser that gets everyone tapping their toes and talking about the good old days.
- Til Death Do Us Part – This modern-day wedding may be a complete disaster for the couple—but it’s a guaranteed hit for your event. Bursting with eccentric characters and unexpected twists, this theme invites guests to witness the chaos unfold from the ceremony to the reception. Perfect for bachelor and bachelorette parties or lively ticketed events, it delivers plenty of laughs and just enough drama to make everyone grateful it wasn’t their big day.
- The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year – If you’re looking to add a little holiday spirit to your festivities, this theme is the gift that keeps on giving. Set at an office holiday party that quickly goes off the rails, the evening unwraps a mystery involving a washed-up comedian, suspicious coworkers, and a motive that’s anything but merry. Full of festive fun and unexpected twists, it’s a perfect fit for winter teambuilders and seasonal celebrations. Just make sure you read the memo… someone’s been naughty.
Perfect for:
- Adult birthdays
- Date nights with a twist
- Fundraisers and public shows
- Bachelor/Bachelorette Parties
No Restrictions Themes: Turning Up the Volume on the Mystery
For the crowd that can handle a little scandal—and loves every second of it—No Restrictions themes turn up the heat. These murder mystery party themes come with a warning: the humor is more suggestive (but never explicit) and the characters? Let’s just say they have strong personalities.
This is the show you book when you want something outrageous, unforgettable, and slightly inappropriate (in the best way). But even with the freedom to get wild, these shows are still professionally run and tightly structured. It’s immersive theater, just with a little extra bite. These themes are 18+.
These themes will contain: Affairs, innuendo, alcohol references, drug references
- I Love the 80s to Death – It’s the 1980s, and the stage is set for an electrifying Battle of the Bands—where egos are high, stakes are higher, and one wrong note could turn deadly. Behind the scenes, tensions rise as rival musicians compete for fame, fortune, and the spotlight. Packed with nostalgic references and big hair energy, this theme channels the iconic rock-and-roll spirit of the decade, delivering a high-octane mystery that’s equal parts retro and riveting.
- Good Riddance – One of the newest additions to the lineup, Good Riddance dives headfirst into a quintessential 1990s rivalry: two shopping malls, side by side, battling for dominance. With reputations—and revenue—on the line, it’s only a matter of time before things turn cutthroat. Whether you lived through the ’90s or just have a soft spot for the era’s unforgettable pop culture, this theme serves up a wave of nostalgia that’ll have you feeling like a mallrat all over again.
Best for:
- Bachelor/Bachelorette parties
- Adult celebrations
- Edgy late-night events
- Private parties where nothing’s off limits
Why Ratings Matter When Planning Your Murder Mystery Party Game
Trying to DIY a murder mystery game night often leads to second-guessing the tone. Will this joke land? Is that character too risqué? Is Aunt Margaret going to walk out?
When you hire The Murder Mystery Company, you skip all that stress. Every show has been professionally written, cast, and tested for just the right balance of intrigue and hilarity. All you have to do is pick your rating—Kids, Adults, or No Restrictions—and let the pros take care of the rest. Their experienced consultants are available to guide you through the content of each theme, ensuring you have a clear understanding of what to expect and helping you choose the best fit for your event.
Don’t Just Throw a Party—Throw a Professionally Run Mystery Event
Whether you’re planning a themed mystery party for your book club or a no-holds-barred night of laughs with your favorite crew, The Murder Mystery Company has a theme and rating that fits.
🎭 Call 888-643-2583 or fill out a quick form on the page you’re currently on to start planning your interactive mystery game today.
Host your own Mystery Party!
Our Murder Mystery Experts are excited to talk to you about your personalized party plans.
trending posts
