What’s better than catching a killer? Bragging rights.

That’s why murder mystery party awards are more than just a cherry on top—they’re the confetti cannon of the whole experience. From “Best Dressed” to “Dead Last Place,” handing out clever titles (and equally clever prizes) turns a great night into a legendary one.

Every event with The Murder Mystery Company wraps up with a dramatic reveal—and a certificate ceremony worthy of a standing ovation. While guests take home themed awards as a keepsake, you’re welcome to sweeten the deal with your own creative prizes to match.

What You’ll Find in This Post:

• Awards guests will love
• Prize ideas for each winner
• Why fun categories matter

Let’s break down the top awards you can expect and what kinds of prizes pair perfectly with each one.

---

Detective of the Night

The Sleuths Who Solved It All

This one’s the big kahuna. It goes to the team that correctly identifies the murderer, their motive, and the opportunity—and backs it up with some good ol’ detective reasoning.

Prize Ideas:

• Magnifying glass trophy
• Gift cards (crime-solving coffee, anyone?)
• Mini detective kits
• Personalized “Case Closed” notebooks

---

Best Dressed

The Guest Who Slayed the Theme

Whether it’s a 1920s gangster suit, a feathered masquerade look, or full-on 80s glam, this award celebrates commitment to the aesthetic and encourages guests to delve deeper into the atmosphere of your theme.

Prize Ideas:

• Costume jewelry or accessories such as a cigarette holder, necklace, or pocket watch
• Themed candles (think: blood orange scent)
• A mini mirror compact (so they can admire their triumphant style)
• A photo frame to display their winning look (perhaps pair it with a polaroid shot on the spot)

---

Best Suspect

The Character Who Had Everyone Suspicious

This one’s for the guest who stayed deep in character and made you question everything. They raised eyebrows, dropped hints, and maybe even had a convincing alibi.

Prize Ideas:

• A dramatic feather pen
• Handcuffs (preferably with a key, of course)
• A fake mustache kit or glasses disguise
• Detective novels or true crime books

---

Best Performer

The One Who Deserves an Oscar

Some guests were born to monologue. This award is for the person who fully embraced the drama—tears, betrayal, accents and all. They don’t even have to be a suspect—maybe they stole the spotlight with an Oscar-worthy performance during one of the improvisation minigames.

Prize Ideas:

• Mini trophy or clapboard
• Local theater or cinema gift card
• Theater mask keychain or pin
• Tiny toy microphone

---

Dead Last Place

Wrong Guess, Right Attitude

Not everyone can be Sherlock. But guessing the wrong killer with confidence deserves its own applause. This is the light-hearted laugh everyone remembers.

Prize Ideas:

• Mug that says “Clueless”
• A small bag of “evidence” (aka candy)
• A goofy brain teaser or puzzle
• Mini crime scene tape roll

---

Why Awards Boost the Fun

• They get everyone invested. Suddenly, everyone wants to play their part and think like a detective.
• They encourage costumes and creativity. No more last-minute Target runs—people come ready.
• They make your event memorable. Guests leave with a story and a souvenir.

The best part? When you book with The Murder Mystery Company, these awards are all part of the experience. Every show ends with a ceremony, complete with paper certificates guests can take home. For team awards, everyone on the winning squad gets one—no sleuth left behind.

---

Call in the Pros—We Bring the Awards and the Applause

Let The Murder Mystery Company do the dirty work. With professionally trained actors, engaging themes, and a flair for unforgettable fun, they’ll turn your evening into a blockbuster event.

Call 888-643-2583 or fill out one of the contact forms on the website to get started. Whether you’re planning a private party, corporate event, or family reunion, they’ve got your mystery—and your awards—covered.