Planning a 1950s murder mystery party? Before the suspects arrive and the clues start flying, there’s one mystery you’ll want to solve ahead of time: what’s on the menu? A themed party is only as good as its atmosphere, and nothing transports guests back to the age of jukeboxes and milkshakes like the right food.

But let’s be honest—between creating the guest list, decorating the “crime scene,” and figuring out who’s going to play dead, cooking up food ideas may not be the vibe. That’s why The Murder Mystery Company can save your life (or someone else’s) with some tips. If you’re hungry for ideas, let’s dive into some classic 1950s flavors that pair perfectly with a murder mystery dinner party game.

---

Classic 1950s Diner-Inspired Dishes to Die For

Think of a 1950s themed mystery party like a stroll into a retro diner—if that diner had a side of scandal. To keep things authentic and easy, build your menu around these staples:

Burgers and Fries:
You can’t go wrong with the king and queen of the diner scene. Set up a burger bar with toppings galore, or bring in sliders for a cute, crowd-pleasing touch. Add some hand-cut fries or even crinkle fries for that extra throwback vibe. If you’d like to go a step further, you can even purchase baskets and burger wrappers which can be as simple as snagging some butcher paper.

Meatloaf and Mashed Potatoes:
Feeling a little more home-cooked? Nothing says “American comfort food” like a juicy meatloaf and a pile of buttery mashed potatoes. Bonus points if you serve it on vintage-style trays. Once everyone is properly fed, then you can really dive into the meat-and-potatoes of the mystery.

Deviled Eggs & Jell-O Molds:
A must-have at every retro party buffet. Deviled eggs are the ultimate finger food, and colorful Jell-O molds (especially ones with fruit suspended in them) give off some serious mid-century energy—just creepy enough for a murder mystery event.

---

Sock Hop Snacks for Sleuthing Between Scenes

As your guests mingle, interrogate, and uncover clues during the interactive mystery game, keep them fueled with easy-to-grab bites that won’t interrupt the drama.

Pigs in a Blanket:
A retro classic that’s as snackable as it is adorable. Perfect for sleuthing on the move.

Cheese Balls & Crackers:
Give the table a little pizzazz with a cheddar cheese ball rolled in crushed nuts, served alongside buttery crackers.

Deviled Eggs & Jell-O Molds:
Don’t forget the most devilish of hors d’oeuvres. Deviled eggs bring the perfect balance of creamy and snappy, while Jell-O molds add a splash of color and a whisper of “suburban secrets.”

---

Beverages That Raise the Stakes

Whether your crowd is sipping or swigging, drinks can enhance the atmosphere and help get those alibis flowing.

Non-Alcoholic Retro Sips:

• Root Beer Floats: The king of the soda shop. Scoop in some vanilla ice cream, pour over root beer, and prepare for frothy nostalgia.
• Shirley Temples: Lemon-lime soda, grenadine, and a maraschino cherry = innocence in a glass. Until someone drops dead, of course.
• Cream Sodas & Orange Crush: Serve in glass bottles for authenticity, or line them up at a self-serve station with paper straws. A lot of soda brands still sell bottles with their classic vintage labels.

Cocktails for some Liquid Courage:

• Old Fashioned: Classic, bold, and slightly mysterious—just like your soon-to-be-victim.
• Manhattan: Strong enough to interrogate suspects, smooth enough to keep secrets.
• Pink Lady: A frothy, gin-based cocktail that fits the aesthetic and tastes like mischief.
• Tom Collins: Light, lemony, and perfect for solving murders—or at least pretending to. Give it a twist and call it a Tom Killins.

Want to go all out? Set up a “Dead Men Drink No Tales” bar with custom signs, themed garnishes, and perhaps a signature cocktail like “The Smoking Gun” or “Bloody Mary.”

---

The Sweet End to a Killer Night

Whether or not your guests figure out whodunnit, they should all leave satisfied—and dessert is the perfect final clue to your culinary success.

Milkshakes:
Blend up chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla classics. Serve in tall glasses with whipped cream and a cherry on top for the full soda-shop effect.

Banana Cream Pie or Cherry Pie Slices:
Single-serving slices make it easy to keep guests focused on solving the mystery… not struggling to cut a slice.

Cupcakes with Crime Scene Toppers:
Add some edible mystery flair with toppers shaped like magnifying glasses, knives, or little red “X”s. Red icing can give it the sinister look you’re pining for.

---

Let The Murder Mystery Company Handle the Rest

You’ve got the flavor—now bring the fun. Planning a murder mystery game night is about more than props and pie. The Murder Mystery Company brings the story, the actors, and the energy to turn your retro bash into a full-blown whodunnit.

With a theme like “A Dance with Death” that’s made for the 1950s, and shows that work around dinner service (even a good old-fashioned buffet), you can enjoy your own party without stress. Just sit back, sip your milkshake, and let the mystery unfold around you.

So instead of spending hours planning your own DIY murder mystery party, get help from the pros. Call 888-643-2583 or fill out the contact form on the page you’re viewing now to start planning your unforgettable 1950s mystery dinner party.

Because the only thing better than serving up meatloaf… is serving up justice.