This summer, ditch the same old cookout routine and give your guests something they’ll really sink their teeth into—a murder mystery summer party. Nothing gets people talking (and accusing each other) quite like a good ol’ fashioned whodunit with a side of sunshine.

Whether you’re planning a birthday, reunion, or just want to be the host with the most (suspicion), The Murder Mystery Company brings everything you need for an unforgettable summer bash: costumed actors, hilarious plots, props, and a crime that begs to be solved. All you have to do is pick your theme, your snacks, and your crime scene location.

Hot Weather, Cool Themes: Summer-Ready Mystery Options

Not all murder mysteries are created equal—some were made for summer. The Murder Mystery Company offers a whole lineup of interactive mystery game themes, but here are a few that pair perfectly with longer days and iced drinks:

I Love the 80s to Death – It’s neon lights, big hair, and the untamed spirit of sex, drugs, and rock and roll. A perfect choice for those ready to dive headfirst into the wild energy of 1980s nostalgia.

Good Riddance – If you’re aiming for that iconic ’90s MTV Spring Break vibe—complete with poolside energy and throwback flair—this theme is the perfect fit.

Death of a Gangster – A 1920s speakeasy soiree where crime is high and morals are low. Perfect for jazzing up your patio or backyard.

Til Death Do Us Part – A wedding reception turns deadly… and no, it’s not just because of the chicken dance.

A Dance with Death – Nothing says summer quite like gathering at the local burger joint with friends, enjoying milkshakes, and soaking in the sounds of classic rock ’n’ roll. This school sock hop-themed mystery brings all the charm of the 1950s—with just the right twist of suspense to keep things interesting.

Each one is a themed mystery party with a full storyline, character assignments, and twists that keep your guests guessing until the very last gasp.

Killer Food Pairings for Your Mystery Dinner Party

No party is complete without food—and when the vibe is murderously fun, your menu can match the mystery. Here’s how to pair some tasty treats with your theme:

Personal Pan Pizzas for Good Riddance – The perfect grab-and-go while solving a crime. Bonus points for Pizza Hut-style boxes.

Slider Bar + Milkshakes for A Dance with Death – Nostalgic comfort food fits perfectly with this throwback vibe.

Loaded Nachoes for I Love the 80s to Death – With jalapeños, cheese, chili, and a side of drama. A great pairing for hotdogs with all the fixings.

Pasta Buffet + Cannoli for Death of a Gangster – Serve up some vintage Italian flair and channel your inner mob boss.

Mini Quiches + Wedding Cake Pops for Til Death Do Us Part – A classy menu for an un-classy crime.

Even if you opt for picnic tables or a backyard buffet, the right food adds flavor to the fun. Don’t overthink it—finger food means less mess, more mingling, and no missing clues.

Backyard Drama Without the DIY Drama

With The Murder Mystery Company, you don’t have to lift a finger (except to point one dramatically at the suspected killer). Professional actors bring the whole experience to life, complete with engaging performances, prop kits, and smooth storytelling that keeps guests laughing, sleuthing, and snapping selfies. Whether you’re throwing your party under twinkle lights, in a rented venue, or inside with the AC cranked, a murder mystery event fits any space. You can even build your own ambiance with some simple additions: string lights, faux crime scene tape, inflatable pool toys, or tiki torches.

Planning’s a breeze when someone else handles the mystery. You pick the theme, set the guest list, maybe cook a few deviled eggs—and let The Murder Mystery Company do the rest.

🔍 Want to throw a party they’ll never forget (even if they were the victim)?
Call 888-643-2583 or fill out one of the contact forms on the page you’re on now to start planning your murder mystery summer party with The Murder Mystery Company today.