Speak to a public show representative
(888) 659-2952

As Seen on ABC's "Shark Tank"!

Murder Mystery Dinner Theater at The Old Spaghetti Factory

Murder Mystery Dinner Theater Phoenix at the Old Spaghetti Factory

Want to experience an unforgettable night out in Phoenix? The Murder Mystery Company invites you to an immersive dinner theater experience at The Old Spaghetti Factory on Central Avenue — a downtown Phoenix institution with over a century of history and a dining room unlike any other. Antique lighting, stained glass, and a refurbished trolley car at the center of it all set the stage for an evening where the atmosphere does half the work. Professional actors weave a live, comedic whodunit through your meal as you and your table gather clues, question suspects, and race to solve the crime before the night is out.

Upcoming Public Murder Mystery Shows at The Old Spaghetti Factory

Our public murder mystery dinner theater events take place multiple times per month at The Old Spaghetti Factory.

The Old Spaghetti Factory
The Old Spaghetti Factory 1418 North Central Avenue, Phoenix, AZ 85004
PRICE
$69 + fees per person
DURATION
Approximately 2.5 Hours
ARRIVAL TIME
For the best experience, arrive prior to the start time of the show. Doors open 30 minutes before the show start time.
VIEW UPCOMING SHOWTIMES

Upcoming Dinner Theater shows at The Old Spaghetti Factory in Phoenix, AZ

A murder mystery show

What to Expect at a Phoenix Murder Mystery Dinner

The Murder Mystery Company creates a fully interactive theater experience, where the audience becomes part of the investigation.

As soon as guests arrive at the venue, they are greeted by actors already in character and introduced to the story. Some guests may even be selected to play suspects in the mystery.

During the evening you will:

  • Interact with professional actors performing the mystery
  • Work with your table to investigate clues
  • Question suspects and gather information
  • Solve the crime before the show ends
  • Enjoy a full three-course dinner while the story unfolds

The experience is often compared to a live-action version of the game Clue, with plenty of comedy, audience participation, and surprises.

Even if you're not chosen as a suspect, every guest participates in the investigation as a detective working alongside their table team.

DINNER MENU

Dinner is served during the show and included with your ticket.

Dinner menu item
APPETIZER: A Crisp Garden Salad with Creamy Pesto Dressing served with Fresh Bread. (Allergen Info: Contains Dairy, Eggs, and Soy)
MAIN COURSE (PICK ONE): Spinach and Cheese Ravioli
Spicy Spaghetti Vesuvius
Lasagna
Breast of Chicken Fettuccini
DESSERT: Spimone Ice Cream
One soft drink (no refills) is included with the meal. There is a cash/credit card bar available for additional beverages.

Our 2026 Theme Schedule

The themes of our shows change monthly.

Guests are encouraged to dress for the theme if they wish, though costumes are optional.

Inside The Old Spaghetti Factory

The Venue:

The Old Spaghetti Factory

The Old Spaghetti Factory is a downtown Phoenix landmark with a history as rich as its menu. The restaurant occupies a building that was originally constructed in 1921 as two separate residences — the Cole Mansion and the Baker House — later joined into one and eventually reimagined as the beloved pasta destination it is today. Decorated with antique lighting, intricate stained glass, large colorful booths, and a restored Phoenix Railway trolley car that guests can actually dine in, the space has a warmth and character that sets it apart from anywhere else in the city. It's the kind of place that becomes a tradition — and the perfect backdrop for a night of mystery.

Parking
Free On-Site Parking & Street Parking

Perfect for Date Nights, Groups, and Celebrations

Many guests attend our Phoenix murder mystery dinners for special occasions such as:

Date Nights
Date Nights
Birthday Celebrations
Birthday Celebrations
Bachelor and Bachelorette Parties
Bachelor and Bachelorette Parties
Friend group outings
Friend group outings
Unique weekend activities
Unique weekend activities
Private murder mystery event setup

Private Murder Mystery Events in Phoenix

In addition to public dinner shows, The Murder Mystery Company also hosts private events and parties in the Phoenix area.

Private murder mystery experiences can be hosted at:

  • Corporate events
  • Holiday parties
  • Team building events
  • Private celebrations
  • Weddings and rehearsal dinners

Request information about hosting a private murder mystery event in Phoenix

Or call (888) 643-2583 to speak with our event planning team.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there an age limit?
There is no strict age limit for our shows, but we generally recommend them for guests ages 13 and up. The majority of attendees are adults, and our performances carry a PG-10 to PG-13 rating. While there is no swearing or graphic content, the show does include some adult humor and innuendos that younger audiences may not fully appreciate. We do not offer a children's menu or reduced pricing for younger guests.
What should I wear?
There's no formal dress code — dinner casual is perfectly appropriate for any of our shows. That said, dressing to the theme is always a fun option, and we do hand out a Best Costume award at the end of the evening. Whether you come dressed to impress or keep it casual, you'll fit right in.
How are we seated?
Seating is handled by our host at the door based on party size. Tables seat up to 10 guests, so make sure your whole group arrives and queues up together to ensure everyone is seated side by side for the full experience.
Is the show appropriate for kids?
We recommend our shows for guests ages 13 and up. There's no graphic content or profanity, but the performances do include adult humor and innuendos that may not be suitable for younger children. Most attendees are adults, and there is no kids' menu or difference in ticket pricing for younger guests.
Can we book a private event?
Absolutely! Private events are a fantastic option for birthdays, corporate outings, holiday gatherings, and more. Give us a call at (888) 643-2583 to connect with one of our event planners, who will walk you through everything involved in putting together a private party.
Do you offer gift cards?
We do! Gift cards are available for purchase through our website via our third-party partner, GiftUp, and can be redeemed on Eventbrite when booking dinner theater tickets. Please keep in mind that gift cards apply to public show ticket purchases only and cannot be used toward private event bookings. Purchase yours here!
Is there parking nearby?
The Old Spaghetti Factory has its own parking lot located behind the building, with additional street parking available in the surrounding area.
Can I make dietary accommodations?
The Old Spaghetti Factory is able to accommodate vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free diets. If you have additional dietary restrictions or specific ingredient questions, we recommend reaching out to the restaurant directly ahead of your visit so they can make sure everything is arranged for you.
Where is the show located?
This show takes place at The Old Spaghetti Factory, located at 1418 N Central Ave, Phoenix, AZ 85004, just minutes from downtown Phoenix.
Is Dinner included with the ticket?
Yes — your ticket covers both the show and a full three-course dinner, including an appetizer, entrée, and dessert. No need to worry about a separate dinner reservation; it's all part of the experience.
What happens if I arrive late?
To keep the show running smoothly for all guests, we are unable to admit latecomers once the doors have closed. We recommend arriving at least 30 minutes before your show's start time to get settled and make the most of the evening.
Are Murder Mystery Company dinner shows good for large groups, private events, or corporate parties?
The Old Spaghetti Factory's central Phoenix location makes it an easy destination for groups coming in from across the metro area. Our shows are a natural fit for team builders, holiday parties, birthday celebrations, and corporate events of all kinds — the interactive format keeps everyone engaged from the first clue to the final reveal. Reach out to our event planning team at (888) 643-2583, available Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 7 PM ET, to start planning.
How do I get to The Old Spaghetti Factory from downtown Phoenix?
The Old Spaghetti Factory is located just about 1.5 miles north of downtown Phoenix at 1418 N Central Ave — a short drive or an easy light rail ride from the city center. We recommend plugging the address into Google Maps or Waze for the most current route based on traffic.
How do I get to The Old Spaghetti Factory using public transit?
The Old Spaghetti Factory is one of the most transit-friendly venues on our schedule. The McDowell/Central Avenue Light Rail Station is located directly across from the restaurant, making it a straight shot from anywhere along the Valley Metro Rail line with no rideshare needed. We recommend using the Valley Metro app for real-time arrival information before heading out.
Have questions? Call our murder mystery experts at (888) 659-2952