Greetings Detectives!

Due to the coronavirus concerns, The Murder Mystery Company will be postponing all public shows between now and September 1st, 2020.

We will be free rescheduling all reservations upon our return. We also have a new Zoom Murder Mystery Product for a live virtual murder mystery experience that you can exchange your tickets for. Let us know if you would like more information about Zoom Murder Mystery Shows.

Our box office will also be closing during this period, however, we will have limited availability via email at [email protected].

This has been a difficult time for many different industries, and live, local theater is no exception. We appreciate your understanding during this period.

The Murder Mystery Company / Dinner Theater / Murder Mystery Dinner Theater in New York, NY

Murder Mystery Dinner Theater in NYC, New York

Sorry Detective! We don’t have any open shows or cases here at the moment. Check back again soon!

Hilton Garden Inn New York

206 E 52nd St, New York, NY 10022 View Map

Dinner Theater at Hilton Garden Inn

Hilton Garden Inn New York is an atmospheric and upscale venue that sets the stage for a night out that’ll quickly turn into an exciting crime scene.

Our murder mystery dinners in New York City usually sell out, so make sure to reserve your spot early. Your ticket includes your 3-course meal, world-renowned immersive murder mystery dinner show, and a chance to win one of our many award certificates!

Extra Driving Info

  • Please enter Hilton Garden Inn New York Hotel and stay in the lobby until doors open to the bar/event space.
  • The bar event space is beyond the elevators, facing the front entrance.

Hilton Garden Inn New York Dinner Menu

First Course
  • Tossed Green Salad
  • with Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Red Onions with Champagne Vinaigrette
Main Course
  • Chicken Marsala — D
  • Chicken breast with seasoned mushrooms, onions, fresh garlic sauteed in a marsala wine.
  • Pasta Primavera V
  • grilled fresh vegetables and rigatoni pasta in a creamy alfredo sauce with shaved parmesan.
Third Course
  • New York Cheesecake

Additional Venue Info

  • Special dietary needs can be met with 72 hours advance notice.
  • If you have a food allergy please call us at (888) 643-2583.
  • This venue is wheelchair accessible.
  • Valet parking only at $15 per car. Street parking is available on a first come first served basis.
  • Public WiFi is available.
  • The Murder Mystery Company Reviews

Get an in-depth look into how your mystery will unfold!

Dinner and a Show
in New York, NY

The Murder Mystery Co. has arrived on the scene in New York City with an unforgettable murder mystery dinner theater experience! Be a part of a hilarious show while feasting on a delicious three course meal.

You should be on the lookout though, because someone just dropped dead and your fellow dinner guests are looking a little suspicious. Interrogate the suspects, gather clues, and hunt down the killer before it’s too late!

Dinner and a Show
in New York, NY

The Murder Mystery Co. has arrived on the scene in New York City with an unforgettable murder mystery dinner theater experience! Be a part of a hilarious show while feasting on a delicious three course meal.

You should be on the lookout though, because someone just dropped dead and your fellow dinner guests are looking a little suspicious. Interrogate the suspects, gather clues, and hunt down the killer before it’s too late!

Have questions? Call our murder mystery experts at (888) 643-2583