COVID-19 Update: The Murder Mystery Company is currently scheduling private, in-person events following up-to-date safety guidelines. (For show requests please call one of our experts at (888) 643-2583).

Going Out?

Our in-person private party murder mysteries are available to be booked!

Plan My Event

Staying In?

Our Zoom Murder Mystery Parties hosted by Detective Ness are the perfect way to spice up your night in!

Schedule My Zoom Party
The Murder Mystery Company / Dinner Theater / Murder Mystery Dinner Theater in New Jersey

Murder Mystery Dinner Theater in New Jersey

Sorry Detective! We don’t have any open shows or cases here at the moment. Check back again soon!

Elk’s Lodge

50 Hinchman Ave, Wayne, NJ 07470 View Map

Dinner Theater at Elk’s Lodge

Elk’s Lodge is situated in a lovely location right by the High Mountain Reserve Park. Feasting on your tasty meal almost helps you forget someone just dropped dead in front of you!

Our murder mystery dinners in New Jersey usually sell out, so make sure to reserve your spot early. Your ticket includes your 3-course meal, world-renowned immersive murder mystery dinner show, and a chance to win one of our many award certificates!

Extra Driving Info

  • Look for the big sign for Elk’s Lodge. There’s parking in the side lot.
  • Enter through the side or front doors.
  • Sit in the lobby and grab a drink until the doors to the event open!

Elk’s Lodge New Jersey Dinner Menu

First Course
  • A Crisp Garden Salad
  • with golden Italian Dressing, and Rolls
Main Course
  • Chicken Marsala — D
  • with potatoes and seasonal vegetable
  • Fried Flounder
  • with tartar sauce on the side as well as potatoes and seasonal vegetables
  • Vegetarian Lasagna — V
Third Course
  • Chocolate Cake
  • D — DEFAULT SELECTION — If menu selections are not made prior to the date of the show, this option will be chosen for you by default.
  • V — Vegetarian Option
  • G — Gluten Free Option

Additional Venue Info

  • This venue requires that you check your coat upon arrival.
  • This venue is wheelchair accessible.
  • Guests may enjoy free parking on site.
  • If you have a food allergy please call us at (888) 643-2583.
  • Drinks and gratuity are not included in the price of admission.
  • Alcoholic beverages are available for purchase during the show.

Get an in-depth look into how your mystery will unfold!

Dinner and a Show
in New Jersey

The Murder Mystery Co. is bringing New Jersey an immersive dinner to die for! You and your team will be transformed into sleuths and suspects when someone drops dead faster than you can say “Waiter, there’s a dead body in my soup.”

Something about this situation seems a little fishy… You’ll need to analyze the evidence over a three-course meal in this unforgettable dinner theater experience. Best of luck catching the killer, Detective!

A Killer Party Idea

Let’s leave the mystery out of the planning. Send us a little bit more information about your event and we’ll get you one step closer to uncovering the killer!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Dinner and a Show
in New Jersey

The Murder Mystery Co. is bringing New Jersey an immersive dinner to die for! You and your team will be transformed into sleuths and suspects when someone drops dead faster than you can say “Waiter, there’s a dead body in my soup.”

Something about this situation seems a little fishy… You’ll need to analyze the evidence over a three-course meal in this unforgettable dinner theater experience. Best of luck catching the killer, Detective!

Have questions? Call our murder mystery experts at (888) 643-2583
© 2019 American Immersion Theater. All rights reserved.