Greetings Detectives!

Due to the coronavirus concerns, The Murder Mystery Company will be postponing all public shows between now and September 1st, 2020.

We will be free rescheduling all reservations upon our return. We also have a new Zoom Murder Mystery Product for a live virtual murder mystery experience that you can exchange your tickets for. Let us know if you would like more information about Zoom Murder Mystery Shows.

Our box office will also be closing during this period, however, we will have limited availability via email at [email protected].

This has been a difficult time for many different industries, and live, local theater is no exception. We appreciate your understanding during this period.

The Murder Mystery Company / Dinner Theater / Murder Mystery Dinner Theater in Cincinnati, OH

Murder Mystery Dinner Theater near Cincinnati, Ohio

Sorry Detective! We don’t have any open shows or cases here at the moment. Check back again soon!

The Old Spaghetti Factory

6320 S Gilmore Rd, Fairfield, OH 45014 View Map

Dinner Theater at The Old Spaghetti Factory

For fifty years, The Old Spaghetti Factory has been a staple in the states. They’re serving up our twist on “dinner and a show” in many locations, including Cincinnati, Ohio. The show combines the best of OSF food and immersion theater for a magnificent experience to dazzle your senses. Put on your detective hat, dust off your magnifying glass, and solve a case that will keep you guessing (and laughing) until the end!

Our shows usually sell out, so make sure to reserve your spot early. Your ticket includes your 3-course meal, world-renowned immersive murder mystery dinner show, and a chance to win one of our many award certificates!

Extra Driving Info

  • The Fairfield location of The Old Spaghetti Factory is located next to Red Lobster in the Cincinnati Mills Mall parking lot.

The Old Spaghetti Factory Cincinnati Dinner Menu

First Course
  • A Crisp Garden Salad
  • with creamy pesto dressing served with fresh bread
Main Course
  • Spaghetti with Mushroom Sauce — DV
  • From-scratch marinara sauce topped with freshly sautéed seasoned mushrooms.
  • Spaghetti Vesuvius
  • Contains Chicken, Beef, and Pork: A spicy blend of tender all natural chicken, sausage, and our handmade meatballs with green peppers and onions. Seasoned with Tabasco and cayenne pepper.
  • Spinach Tortellini with Alfredo Sauce
  • Contains Chicken and Pork: Hat shaped pasta, stuffed with a delicious blend of mortadella meat and cheese.
Third Course
  • Spumoni Ice Cream
  • A mix of Cherry, Chocolate, and Pistachio

Additional Venue Info

  • Free on-site parking.
  • Wheelchair accessible.
  • If you have a food allergy please call us at (888) 643-2583.
  • Drinks and gratuity are not included in the price of admission.
  • Alcoholic beverages are available for purchase during the show.
  • Special dietary needs can be met with 72 hours advance notice.

The Murder Mystery Company Reviews

Bethany Quinn
Bethany Quinn
18:43 18 Feb 18
We had an awesome time- the plot was very detailed, with plenty of twists and turns. The actors were excellent and the evening was very entertaining ! A+++
Mickey Lawson
Mickey Lawson
18:38 18 Dec 17
The show was a lot of fun and the cast did a great job of engaging the audience. I would highly recommend this show for any murder mystery fan.
Mary Krummen
Mary Krummen
18:08 11 Mar 18
Fun time, something different to do!
Jeanette Whittington
Jeanette Whittington
14:35 20 Apr 19
My husband and I went for our anniversary. We had a blast! We were sat with a family that we didn’t know but they were so much fun that it wasn’t weird or awkward. I made for a terrible detective though! Just when I thought I knew who the killer was that character was ‘ murdered’! My table didn’t guess the killer right but it was still fun. I did win ‘Best Dressed’ (which was awesome because I never win anything lol). I highly recommend dressing up! It really helps add to the show and makes you feel like part of it. The actors were great trying to keep everyone involved! Other guests were also keeping with the ‘act’ which made it so fun! I meet several awesome people that really made it a fun night. If you want to meet new people or work on social skills this is a great way to do that! The only thing that I would change or suggest is a bathroom break/intermission in the middle. My husband needed a break but didn’t want to leave because he didn’t want to miss anything. So at the end we high tailed it out for the bathrooms instead of mingling and thanking the actors (which they deserved for such a good performance)! I would definitely want to do this again with a group. I would definitely recommend to others!
Faith Colwell
Faith Colwell
17:23 16 Jul 17
Very fun engaging crowd of people.

Get an in-depth look into how your mystery will unfold!

Dinner and a Show
in Cincinnati, OH

There’s a killer on the loose at this hilarious murder mystery dinner in Cincinnati! People are dropping clues left and right, and it’s gonna be up to you to put the pieces of the puzzle together! Solve a hilarious crime while you treat yourself to a delicious 3 course meal.

A murder mystery with The Experts in Mystery Entertaiment isn’t your average dinner show experience. As an audience member, you get to be the star of the show! Get ready for an entertaining night of laughter, dining and mystery. Just be careful! The killer is hiding in plain sight.

Dinner and a Show
in Cincinnati, OH

There’s a killer on the loose at this hilarious murder mystery dinner in Cincinnati! People are dropping clues left and right, and it’s gonna be up to you to put the pieces of the puzzle together! Solve a hilarious crime while you treat yourself to a delicious 3 course meal.

A murder mystery with The Experts in Mystery Entertaiment isn’t your average dinner show experience. As an audience member, you get to be the star of the show! Get ready for an entertaining night of laughter, dining and mystery. Just be careful! The killer is hiding in plain sight.

Have questions? Call our murder mystery experts at (888) 643-2583