COVID-19 Update: The Murder Mystery Company is currently scheduling private, in-person events following up-to-date safety guidelines. (For show requests please call one of our experts at (888) 643-2583).

Going Out?

Our in-person private party murder mysteries are available to be booked!

Plan My Event

Staying In?

Our Zoom Murder Mystery Parties hosted by Detective Ness are the perfect way to spice up your night in!

Schedule My Zoom Party
The Murder Mystery Company / Dinner Theater / Murder Mystery Dinner Theater in Cincinnati, OH

Murder Mystery Dinner Theater near Cincinnati, Ohio

Sorry Detective! We don’t have any open shows or cases here at the moment. Check back again soon!

The Old Spaghetti Factory

6320 S Gilmore Rd, Fairfield, OH 45014 View Map

Dinner Theater at The Old Spaghetti Factory

For fifty years, The Old Spaghetti Factory has been a staple in the states. They’re serving up our twist on “dinner and a show” in many locations, including Cincinnati, Ohio. The show combines the best of OSF food and immersion theater for a magnificent experience to dazzle your senses. Put on your detective hat, dust off your magnifying glass, and solve a case that will keep you guessing (and laughing) until the end!

Our shows usually sell out, so make sure to reserve your spot early. Your ticket includes your 3-course meal, world-renowned immersive murder mystery dinner show, and a chance to win one of our many award certificates!

Extra Driving Info

  • The Fairfield location of The Old Spaghetti Factory is located next to Red Lobster in the Cincinnati Mills Mall parking lot.

The Old Spaghetti Factory Cincinnati Dinner Menu

First Course
  • A Crisp Garden Salad
  • with creamy pesto dressing served with fresh bread
Main Course
  • Spaghetti with Mushroom Sauce — DV
  • From-scratch marinara sauce topped with freshly sautéed seasoned mushrooms.
  • Spaghetti Vesuvius
  • Contains Chicken, Beef, and Pork: A spicy blend of tender all natural chicken, sausage, and our handmade meatballs with green peppers and onions. Seasoned with Tabasco and cayenne pepper.
  • Spinach Tortellini with Alfredo Sauce
  • Contains Chicken and Pork: Hat shaped pasta, stuffed with a delicious blend of mortadella meat and cheese.
Third Course
  • Spumoni Ice Cream
  • A mix of Cherry, Chocolate, and Pistachio
  • D — DEFAULT SELECTION — If menu selections are not made prior to the date of the show, this option will be chosen for you by default.
  • V — Vegetarian Option
  • G — Gluten Free Option

Additional Venue Info

  • Free on-site parking.
  • Wheelchair accessible.
  • If you have a food allergy please call us at (888) 643-2583.
  • Drinks and gratuity are not included in the price of admission.
  • Alcoholic beverages are available for purchase during the show.
  • Special dietary needs can be met with 72 hours advance notice.

The Murder Mystery Company Reviews

The Murder Mystery Company in Cincinnati
The Murder Mystery Company in Cincinnati
4.6
Based on 154 reviews
See all reviewsWrite a review
Tshala Wilson
Tshala Wilson
20:59 06 Feb 21
This was so much fun!!!
Kiley Wessel
Kiley Wessel
00:38 31 Jan 21
GWC Field And Experiential Marketing
GWC Field And Experiential Marketing
19:43 28 Jan 21
Awesome group activity. Had so much fun!!!
Joshua Rudio
Joshua Rudio
23:18 07 Aug 20
Great! Alec is awesome!
Gina Greenwalt (she/her)
Gina Greenwalt (she/her)
01:09 06 Aug 20
Virtual murder mystery felt like it could have been hit or miss - but happy to confirm this was a hit! Our detective/host Eric Banharn was a delight and we had a group of 10 for this mystery. Our host had such great energy and made us all loosen up and have fun. Would recommend to anyone looking for a fun team building event!

Get an in-depth look into how your mystery will unfold!

Dinner and a Show
in Cincinnati, OH

There’s a killer on the loose at this hilarious murder mystery dinner in Cincinnati! People are dropping clues left and right, and it’s gonna be up to you to put the pieces of the puzzle together! Solve a hilarious crime while you treat yourself to a delicious 3 course meal.

A murder mystery with The Experts in Mystery Entertaiment isn’t your average dinner show experience. As an audience member, you get to be the star of the show! Get ready for an entertaining night of laughter, dining and mystery. Just be careful! The killer is hiding in plain sight.

A Killer Party Idea

Let’s leave the mystery out of the planning. Send us a little bit more information about your event and we’ll get you one step closer to uncovering the killer!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Dinner and a Show
in Cincinnati, OH

There’s a killer on the loose at this hilarious murder mystery dinner in Cincinnati! People are dropping clues left and right, and it’s gonna be up to you to put the pieces of the puzzle together! Solve a hilarious crime while you treat yourself to a delicious 3 course meal.

A murder mystery with The Experts in Mystery Entertaiment isn’t your average dinner show experience. As an audience member, you get to be the star of the show! Get ready for an entertaining night of laughter, dining and mystery. Just be careful! The killer is hiding in plain sight.

Have questions? Call our murder mystery experts at (888) 643-2583
© 2019 American Immersion Theater. All rights reserved.