There’s nothing quite like the thrill of a murder mystery—especially when it’s piping through your earbuds while you fold laundry or solving the case of the stubborn pet-stained rug. Whether it’s cold cases or fictional fiascos, murder mystery podcasts deliver all the intrigue of a whodunnit, without needing to untangle a pair of bloody gloves.

But once you’re hooked on solving murders from your couch, it’s only natural to start wondering… what if you could actually be part of the mystery? (Spoiler alert: you can.)

What You’ll Discover in This Blog:

• Top murder mystery podcasts
• What makes each one stand out
• Why listening leaves you wanting more
• Where to turn the drama real
• Who to call when you’re ready

Here’s a roundup of some of the best murder mystery podcasts out there—each one designed to tickle your inner detective and spark some seriously suspicious inspiration.

---

1. Solve – Where You’re the Detective

Each episode of Solve drops you in the middle of a fictional crime, then lets you play detective. You get the suspect interviews, the crime scene details, and just enough time to form a theory before the big reveal.

Why you’ll love it: You’re not just a listener—you’re part of the investigation.

---

2. Deadly Manners – A Dinner Party With a Body Count

Set in the 1950s and dripping in high-society scandal, this audio drama features a blizzard, a blackout, and a killer guest list. Voiced by celebs like Kristen Bell and RuPaul, it’s like listening to Clue come alive—with martinis.

Why you’ll love it: Vintage vibes, biting wit, and a cast that serves drama on a silver platter.

---

3. Sword and Scale – Where True Crime Gets Chilling

Not for the faint of heart, Sword and Scale dives deep into real-life crimes with chilling narration, courtroom audio, and interviews that’ll keep you up at night. It’s raw, riveting, and darkly fascinating.

Why you’ll love it: A deep-dive into the darker corners of the human mind.

---

4. Welcome to Night Vale – Weird, Witty, and Wonderfully Suspicious

Picture a small desert town where every conspiracy theory is true. That’s Night Vale, and every episode delivers surreal mysteries, strange disappearances, and cryptic broadcasts with just enough unease to keep you hooked.

Why you’ll love it: It’s like The Twilight Zone had a lovechild with public radio.

---

5. My Favorite Murder – True Crime with a Side of Sass

Hosted by comedians Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, My Favorite Murder is one part comedy, one part true crime obsession. Each episode mixes chilling murder cases with offbeat banter and real talk about anxiety, justice, and life.

Why you’ll love it: It’s like chatting about serial killers with your funniest friends.

---

6. Crime Junkie – Addictive, Polished, and Perfect for Bingeing

Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat bring a polished, story-driven approach to true crime, with episodes that go down like popcorn. From mysterious disappearances to solved cases with shocking twists, Crime Junkie is a gateway drug to the genre.

Why you’ll love it: Sharp storytelling with heart—and just the right amount of drama.

---

Want to Go Beyond the Headphones?

Let’s face it—murder mystery podcasts are addictive. But there comes a time when just listening isn’t enough. That’s when it’s time to put down the phone and pick up a magnifying glass (or a mask, or a martini glass… you get it).

If you’re ready to experience the drama firsthand, The Murder Mystery Company brings the mystery straight to your party. With live actors, immersive plots, and laugh-out-loud fun, our murder mystery dinner party game gives you and your guests the thrill of the chase—without any of the cleanup.

Whether it’s for a birthday, a team-building event, or just a night that needs some flair, we’ll take care of the crime so you can focus on the fun.

Let’s Plot Something Together
Call 888-643-2583 or fill out a contact form on this page to get started. Your mystery dinner party awaits—and trust us, it’ll be killer.