< Blog Idea Lists

Soundtracks That Set the Scene for a Killer Mystery

April 26, 2025

When the plot thickens and suspicion fills the air, one element can make or break a murder mystery party: the music.
And not just any music—instrumental music. No distracting lyrics, no jarring mood shifts—just pure, spine-tingling atmosphere that keeps everyone guessing.

Bullet Points:

  • Top instrumental artists for suspense
  • Musical styles to fit every theme
  • Planning the perfect mystery night

Here’s a look at the best instrumental artists to bring your mystery to life:


1. Bix Beiderbecke

For a 1920s murder mystery dripping with smoky suspense and hidden danger, Bix Beiderbecke’s cornet sets the perfect mood. His smooth, expressive instrumentals bring the jazz age to life without overpowering the action. Whether the mystery unfolds in a swanky speakeasy or a shady underground club, Beiderbecke’s bittersweet melodies keep guests right on the edge of their seats.

Best for: 1920s speakeasy mysteries, mobster weddings, vintage noir stories


2. L’Attirail

If your murder mystery needs a touch of old-world charm—with a little grit, a little mystery, and a whole lot of character—L’Attirail is the band to beat. Their eclectic mix of Balkan, French, and folk influences creates the perfect soundtrack for a suspenseful evening full of secrets and surprises. Imagine crooks on the run, a stolen treasure, or a clandestine meeting behind velvet curtains.

Best for: Vintage mysteries, European-themed stories, speakeasy settings


3. Jack Jezzro

Looking for a smoother, more sophisticated vibe? Jack Jezzro’s instrumental jazz and lounge tracks bring a rich, velvety feel to any event. His music is polished but never boring—perfect for mysteries that call for elegance with a touch of intrigue. Guests will feel like they’ve stepped straight into a high-end noir film where anyone could be hiding a secret. His albums are neatly sorted by theme and mood, making it a breeze to find the perfect soundtrack for your mystery.

Best for: Classy mysteries, upscale detective stories, noir themes


4. Vitamin String Quartet

Want something a little more playful, but still polished? Vitamin String Quartet takes familiar pop, rock, and indie songs and spins them into elegant string arrangements. Guests get the thrill of recognition, but the fresh spin keeps them slightly off-balance—the perfect mood for a murder mystery game night.

Best for: Lighthearted or elegant mysteries, vintage and contemporary-themed parties


5. Henry Mancini

The grandmaster of classic spy and mystery music, Henry Mancini gave the world unforgettable themes like The Pink Panther and Peter Gunn. His jazzy, mischievous style sets the perfect tone for a whodunnit filled with charm, danger, and clever misdirection. It’s impossible not to feel like a detective on the hunt when Mancini’s sleek brass and piano riffs fill the room.

Best for: Old-school spy mysteries, playful detective stories, glamorous mystery dinners


Plan the Ultimate Mystery Dinner Party

Ready to set the scene, spin the soundtrack, and trap your guests in the ultimate whodunnit? The Murder Mystery Company specializes in creating unforgettable murder mystery parties, complete with professional actors, gripping storylines, and jaw-dropping surprises. Some actor packages come with a full professional sound system and custom-themed music to match the storyline—and the best part is, you can add it to any show!

Skip the DIY headache and let the experts handle it. Call 888-643-2583 or fill out a quick contact form right here on the page to start planning your custom event today. The perfect murder mystery party game is just one phone call away!

Host your own Mystery Party!

Our Murder Mystery Experts are excited to talk to you about your personalized party plans.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.