So you’re heading to a ‘90s murder mystery party—or even better, you’re planning one. You’ve got the intrigue, the alibis, the suspicious stares, and the killer playlist. Now all that’s left is figuring out how to show up looking like a walking time capsule from a decade of baggy jeans, bold patterns, and iconic pop culture.

What you’ll find in this blog:

• Easy outfit ideas from the ’90s
• How to match the mystery theme
• Group costume inspiration
• Tips to elevate the experience

If your outfit isn’t at least a little ridiculous, are you even doing the ’90s right?

---

Grunge Meets Guilt: The Alternative Suspect Look

Nothing says “I might’ve done it, but in an emotionally tortured way” like full-blown grunge.

Go-to pieces:

• Ripped jeans (the baggier, the better)
• Flannel shirt tied around the waist
• Band tee (bonus points for Nirvana, Pearl Jam, or Soundgarden)
• Doc Martens or combat boots

Add a brooding stare, a fake police report, and maybe a mystery involving a lost mixtape, and you’re halfway to solving the case… or committing the crime.

---

Fresh Prints and False Alibis: Embrace the Bold

If your vibe is more “class clown turned prime suspect,” the Fresh Prince of Bel-Air look is where it’s at.

Think:

• Bright colorblocking
• Overalls (one strap down, obviously)
• Bucket hat or high-top fade wig
• Retro sneakers (Reebok Pumps or Air Jordans, anyone?)

This outfit screams fun and innocence…which might just make people overlook the fact that you’ve got the motive and the means.

---

Suits, Slick Hair, and Secrets: The Corporate Culprit

Need a reason to bust out your old prom tux? Go full ‘90s businessman or villain-on-the-rise.

Key elements:

• Boxy suit jacket with shoulder pads
• Skinny tie or bold-patterned tie
• Slicked-back hair (or gelled hair parted down the middle)
• Cell phone prop the size of a loaf of bread

This character practically runs the company—and probably has enemies. Perfect for a power-hungry plot twist in your murder mystery dinner party game.

---

The Group Chat That Kills: Coordinated Outfit Ideas

Planning a themed mystery party for a birthday, bachelor party, or reunion? Dressing as a group adds fun and flair.

Ideas to try:

• Boy Band (each person as a different Backstreet Boy or NSYNC member)
• Sports Team (varsity jackets, sweatbands, letterman jackets)
• TV Sitcom Squad (Think Friends, Saved by the Bell, or Seinfeld)
• Cartoon Criminals (Group of Scooby Doo characters? Someone’s gotta play Shaggy.)

Costumed crews add extra flair to the party and help guests dive headfirst into the immersive experience together.

---

Ready to Throw a Killer ’90s Bash?

A murder mystery game night set in the ‘90s is an unforgettable way to spice up any event, from birthday parties to teambuilders. But if you want it to run as smoothly as Joey’s pickup lines and have everyone talking for years, don’t go it alone.

Call 888-643-2583 or fill out a contact form at The Murder Mystery Company to get expert help planning the ultimate throwback whodunnit.

Because nothing says “iconic party” like shoulder pads, sabotage, and a shocking final twist.