< Blog Tips & Tricks

What to Wear to a Murder Mystery

June 05, 2023

The Ultimate Guide to Rocking Your Murder Mystery Party Outfit

Just imagine this: you’ve been invited to a murder mystery party. You’re excited, buzzing with anticipation. Who will you be? The glamorous starlet with secrets to hide, or perhaps the brooding detective with a keen eye for detail? But as you start to consider the thrilling night of deception and deduction ahead, one question suddenly plagues you: what on earth are you going to wear?

Fret no more. This ultimate guide is here to help you piece together the perfect murder mystery party outfit that will not only help you get into character but also make heads turn. You’ll be as much a part of the mystery as the grand plot itself!

Know Your Murder Mystery Theme

Understanding the theme of the murder mystery is crucial before selecting your outfit. Whether it’s a 1920s Glamour soirée or a Medieval Fantasy gathering, your attire will significantly influence your ability to effectively embody the character and enrich the immersive experience. You can get some themed murder mystery costume ideas from our themes pages – from time period specific attire from the 1920s, 1950s, or 1980s, or classic Hollywood or even holiday themed parties.

Building Your Character

First, let’s get one thing straight: a murder mystery party costume isn’t your average party attire. It’s a chance to be a part of a grand narrative, to bring a character to life. This isn’t just a party; it’s an interactive theater experience! You’re not merely dressing up; you’re building a character from the shoes up.

Let’s start with the basics. You might be given a specific character to portray, or perhaps just a general theme for the party. Either way, you’ve got to keep your character in mind while choosing your outfit. Are you a 1920s flapper or a Victorian dame? Make sure your outfit reflects that. Hit the thrift stores or your grandma’s attic for authentic pieces.

Each character in a murder mystery dinner comes with its own backstory, which may include specific details about their lifestyle, profession, and social status that should ideally be reflected in your attire. Investigating the nuances of your character can help you choose attire that is not only theme-appropriate but also enriches your role’s authenticity.

Delightful and Devious Details

Next, let’s talk accessories. This is where your murder mystery party costume can truly shine. The devil, as they say, is in the details. If your character is a sneaky spy, perhaps a vintage locket with a hidden compartment would suit you. A feathered headband or long string of pearls can transport you back to the Roaring Twenties, while a jeweled brooch or lace gloves might fit a Victorian-themed night perfectly.

Now, let’s address the most crucial element of your murder mystery party outfit: the murder weapon! Or at least, a mock version of it. If your character is the murderer (or a potential suspect), consider how you might discreetly incorporate a prop weapon into your outfit. A toy dagger tucked into a garter belt? A fake poison vial hanging from a necklace?

Shopping Tips for Your Murder Mystery Outfit

Shopping for murder mystery attire can be an exciting venture, whether you’re on a tight budget or ready to spare no expense. Each approach offers its own set of benefits and can significantly influence your experience at the event.

Shopping on a Budget

For those looking to minimize costs, there are several savvy shopping strategies to consider:

  • Thrift Stores and Charity Shops: These are treasure troves for budget-conscious shoppers. You can find unique, vintage pieces that are perfect for various murder mystery themes. From classic trench coats for a detective look to elegant vintage dresses suitable for a 1920s gala, the possibilities are endless. The key is to visit multiple stores and keep an open mind about how you can repurpose items creatively.
  • DIY Costumes: If you have a knack for crafting, consider making your own costume. Use online tutorials to help transform everyday items into period-appropriate attire. For instance, a basic black dress can be enhanced with homemade accessories like a beaded necklace or a headband to fit the Roaring Twenties.
  • Borrow and Swap: Network with friends who may have previously attended costume parties or who might have suitable pieces you can borrow. This approach not only cuts costs but also promotes a sustainable cycle of reuse among communities.

Sparing No Expense

If budget is less of a concern, indulging in a more lavish approach can make your murder mystery experience even more memorable:

  • Specialty Costume Shops: These shops offer high-quality, authentic costumes that can perfectly match your character’s era and status. The advantage of such stores is not only the variety of options but also the quality of the costumes, which often include intricate details that add to the authenticity of your character.
  • Custom Tailored Outfits: For a truly unique and fitting costume, consider having your attire custom-made. This could be particularly appealing for those attending a high-end murder mystery event, or for characters that require a specific look that can’t be easily replicated off-the-shelf.
  • High-End Accessories: Sometimes, all it takes to elevate a costume is one or two luxury accessories. Whether it’s a genuine leather holster for a Wild West sheriff or a designer 1920s-inspired clutch, these items can add a layer of sophistication and realism to your outfit.

In both scenarios, it’s important to remember that the goal is to enhance your enjoyment and engagement with the murder mystery experience. Whether you’re browsing through racks at a thrift store or ordering a bespoke outfit, the process of preparing for the event should be as enjoyable as the event itself. Ultimately, the effort you put into your costume can greatly enrich your role-playing experience, making the night all the more fun and immersive.

Sparkling From Within

Remember, the most important thing is to feel fabulous in whatever you wear. You’re not just playing a part; you’re the star of the show. So, choose an outfit that makes you feel confident, glamorous, and ready for anything. After all, this is your moment to shine – or should we say, sparkle with intrigue?

When it comes to murder mystery party outfits, it’s not about dressing to kill (pun absolutely intended); it’s about embracing a role, being a part of a story, and creating an unforgettable evening. While you’re out there, sleuthing and socializing, don’t forget to strike a pose or two. After all, you’re not just cracking the case – you’re doing it in style. So go ahead, enjoy the thrill of the mystery, the camaraderie of the guests, and of course, the joy of dressing up.

Making Your Murder Mystery Party Dreams a Reality

Who knows? You might just find that the outfit you feared would be a ‘mystery’ to put together, has in fact become the pièce de résistance of your wardrobe. So dust off that feathered hat, polish those vintage shoes, and step into the world of intrigue and excitement that only a murder mystery party can offer.

To get you started, why not contact the Murder Mystery Company today for pricing for your event? They’re always available to help make your murder mystery dreams come true.

Host your own Mystery Party!

Our Murder Mystery Experts are excited to talk to you about your personalized party plans.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.